Slicks or wets?
Kimi Antonelli is world champion: an Italian on top of Formula 1, 73 years after Ascari. The title came in Mexico, but one of the races that paved his way was decided in the pits, before the lights even went out.
A good way to talk about industrial keyboards…
Sepang, Malaysia. The sky over the circuit is leaden grey. Half an hour before the scheduled start a tropical storm breaks out, and the start is pushed back first by half an hour, then by an hour. When the race finally gets under way it isn't raining, but the radar is giving mixed signals, even predicting showers on just some parts of the track.
On the pit wall they have a few seconds to decide. Slick tyres, smooth as a billiard ball, which glue the car to dry tarmac and deliver blistering lap times; or intermediates, with grooves that sweep the water out from under the wheels?
Getting it wrong, either way, means throwing the race away. If it rains again, whoever is on slicks will be driving on bars of soap with an uncontrollable car; if the sun comes out, on dry tarmac the cars on intermediates will look like they're standing still compared with those on slicks.
Who made the right call? Red Bull and Mercedes, who started on intermediates. Ferrari and McLaren fitted slicks and threw away their qualifying work in a few laps: Hamilton, second on the grid, dropped all the way to seventeenth.
The moral: there is no best tyre. There is the right tyre for the track conditions on that day. Exactly like keyboards in industry: there is no best one, only the one that fits the job you need it for!
And in industry you have a big advantage over the Formula 1 pit wall. You don't need weather stations to know which keyboard to fit. You know whether the keyboard will work around oil, dust or water, whether operators wear gloves, whether the workstation is washed down every evening.
Yet in most projects the keyboard is chosen last. First the PC, the software, the control cabinet, the monitor. Then someone asks: “what about the keyboard?”. And the cheapest one gets picked.
For a few months everything is fine. Then a key stops responding. The operator presses harder, maybe with a glove on or with the tip of a screwdriver. The key gives up completely and the machine stands still until the spare part arrives. It was a €50 office keyboard. The downtime costs far more.
In industry, the choice usually comes down to two “compounds”: membrane and stainless steel. Let's see when each one wins.
How they are built, in a nutshell
A membrane keyboard is a flat, continuous surface. On top is a polyester or polycarbonate overlay with the keys printed on it. Polyester stands up better to cleaning agents and repeated presses; polycarbonate is cheaper but tends to yellow and crack over time. Underneath is a thin circuit that closes the contact when you press. Often there is a small metal dome that “clicks” to confirm the key has been pressed.
The main advantages of a membrane keyboard are:
- Easy to clean: the continuous surface leaves fewer gaps where dirt and dust can build up.
- Takes up little space: its slim profile makes it easy to integrate into control panels.
- Can be customised: symbols, colours and key layout can be designed around the machine.
- Good value for money: especially when you need dedicated solutions for specific control functions.
A stainless steel keyboard is a different story. Each key is a small piece of stainless steel, mounted on a steel plate and sealed with a gasket. The key travel is short and positive. Our steel keyboards offer front protection up to IP67 and, on keypads, impact resistance up to IK09 and IK10.
The main advantages are:
- High impact resistance: the metal construction protects the keyboard from mechanical stress.
- Vandal-resistant: many models are also designed for public workstations or ones used by many people.
- Built for industrial environments: properly protected versions can cope with dust, humidity and dirt.
- Long-lasting: the sturdy structure suits workstations under heavy use.

Side by side, situation by situation
Neither one always wins. The winner is the one that suits what happens in front of the keyboard.
| Situation | Membrane | Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Water, splashes, washdowns | Excellent: continuous surface, no gaps | Good: keys sealed by a gasket |
| Dust and dirt | Excellent: dirt can't get in | Excellent with front protection up to IP67 |
| Knocks and impacts | Weak: the overlay gets marked or punctured | Excellent: withstands knocks and impacts |
| Sharp objects (screwdrivers, keys, pens) | Weak: risk of cuts | Excellent |
| Vandalism and public use | Suitable for kiosks in supervised areas, avoid where vandalism is a risk | The natural choice |
| Work gloves | Good with snap domes | Good: short, positive travel |
| Disinfectants and cleaning agents | Good, if the overlay is suitable | Excellent: stainless steel doesn't mind sanitising |
| Long typing sessions | Tiring | Less tiring than membrane |
| Weight and footprint | Minimal | Greater |
| Price | Lower | Higher, but lasts for years |
A note on gloves: a membrane without snap domes gives almost no feedback. With a thick glove the operator can't feel whether the key was pressed and ends up pressing twice. If your team works with gloves, always check this detail. We covered it in depth in this blog article: Ergonomics and Tactile Feedback.
Would you rather see them in action? In about 4 minutes we show you both keyboards up close: where a membrane fits in, what steel can withstand and how to choose the right one for your plant (video in Italian).
▶ Watch the video: Membrane or steel keyboard? Which one to choose for industry
So, which one should you choose?
Choose membrane if:
- you need to integrate it into a machine tool, a panel or a control cabinet, flush-mounted with a very low profile;
- hygiene is the priority, as in food processing, healthcare and laboratories, where the surface is cleaned and sanitised often;
- the keyboard handles just a few commands, such as start, stop, confirmations or recipes, in an environment without impacts;
- you need to keep costs down across many machines.
Choose steel if:
- the keyboard takes knocks, oil splashes, chips or metal dust, as in heavy workshops, quarries and ports;
- the operator works with heavy gloves and tools in hand;
- the workstation is public or unattended, such as kiosks, totems, self-service counters and access control systems;
- it is fitted in control cabins, on industrial vehicles or trains, where vibration and knocks are an everyday thing;
- downtime caused by a broken keyboard costs you more than the keyboard itself.
But how do you know which one really suits your application? We suggest starting with four simple questions.
1. Where will the keyboard be installed?
Machine panel, little space and defined commands? Go for membrane. Impacts, heavy use or risk of damage? Stainless steel is the tougher choice.
2. How much dirt, water or dust will it face?
Both protect well against the elements. What really makes the difference is the IP rating and the installation: if the workstation is washed or gets wet often, always check the protection you need. If the keyboard is cleaned with a pressure washer every day, not even an IP67 front is designed for high-pressure jets: in that case, ask us about our silicone keyboards.
3. How will operators use it?
A keyboard has to be tough, but also comfortable and precise. With gloves, what counts is large keys and good tactile feedback, meaning you can feel that the key has been pressed. There are membranes with a clearly perceptible click and steel keyboards designed for intensive use. The choice depends on the commands and how often they are used.
4. How much would machine downtime cost you?
This may be the most important question. The purchase price is only part of the cost: service life, maintenance and downtime count too. A cheap but unsuitable keyboard costs more in the long run. Likewise, buying steel when membrane would do is money you could have saved.
The best choice isn't necessarily the most expensive or the toughest one. It's the right one for the job it has to do.
Not sure? Ask the people who see them at work every day
Choosing the wrong keyboard doesn't make noise straight away. It does six months later, with a key that doesn't respond and a line at a standstill.
Choosing the right one takes two minutes. Write to us or call +39 0429 653281 and tell us where the keyboard will work: the environment, who uses it, whether gloves are worn, how it's cleaned. Advice from one of our technicians is free: we'll tell you whether a membrane is enough, whether you need steel or whether another solution is better.
And you don't have to take our word for it: TRY BEFORE YOU BUY! You can test the keyboard for 15 days in your own department (for catalogue models in stock). If it doesn't improve the quality of your work, send it back at no extra cost.
P.S. Do you have special requirements, such as a layout in another language, an integrated pointing device or panel mounting? Mention it in the form: many of our keyboards are born exactly this way. Like the one with a Hungarian layout, a large touchpad and an integrated numeric keypad, created to get rid of the mouse and cables at a workstation with very little space.
P.P.S. How did the race end? Not like the cover image. The heart wants what it wants, and that image shows how I would have liked it to end. Hamilton first, Antonelli second, I'll leave the rest of the order to others. The real podium was 1st Verstappen, 2nd Antonelli, 3rd Hamilton. And my idol Lewis pulled off a real miracle to climb onto the third step of that podium. Phenomenal!

